Census Watch

List of Organizations AGAINST and SUPPORTING the Government’s Position on the cancellation of the Long Form of the 2011 Census.

This alphabetical list is a work in progress.  It is continuously being updated.  At the Bottom of this table you will find references to media roundups, a list of  lists and actions as they are discovered.  Do share!

[Updated Sept.  3, 00:37 EST] Also thank to Compte sur moi ! where many of the pdf letters are posted!

Organizations & Individuals AGAINST the Government Decision Organizations & Individuals SUPPORTING the Government Decision

  1. Alberta Health Services, CEO Dr. Stephen Duckett
  2. Alberta Professional Planners Institute
  3. Access Alliance Multicultural Health and Community Services
  4. Alliance canadienne des personnes retraitées
  5. Ancestry.ca
  6. Anglican Church of Canada / Église anglicane du Canada
  7. Anne Johnston Health Station
  8. Association des statisticiennes et statisticiens du Québec
  9. Association du Barreau canadien / The Bar Associate of Canada
  10. Association of Canadian Economist / Association canadienne des économistes
  11. Association des Soeurs du Canada
  12. Association canadienne francaise pour avancement de science (ACFAS)
  13. Association féminine d’éducation et d’action sociale (AFEAS)
  14. Association francophone pour le savoir (Acfas)
  15. Association of Canadian Archivists (ACA)
  16. Association of Canadian Map Libraries and Archives (ACMLA) / Association des cartothèques et des archives cartographiques du Canada
  17. Association of Educational Researchers of Ontario
  18. Association of Municipalities of Ontario / Association des municipalités de l’Ontario
  19. Association ontarienne des chercheurs et chercheuses en éducation au ministre Clement (AERO)
  20. Association of Ontario Health Centres
  21. Association of Public Health Epidemiologists in Ontario (APHEO) / Association ontarienne d’épidémiologie et desanté publique
  22. Atlantic Provinces Economics Council / Conseil économique de province de l’atlantique
  23. Larry Bagnell, MP Yukon
  24. BC Library Association
  25. BC Chamber of Commerce
  26. BC Government Employee Union (BCGEU)
  27. Black Creek Community Health Centre
  28. BC Non Profit Housing Association
  29. BC Government and Service Employees’ Union
  30. Bloc Québécois
  31. Burlington Chamber of Commerce
  32. Burnaby Family Life
  33. C.D. Howe Institute
  34. Caledon Institute of Social Policy / Institut Caledon des Politiques Sociales
  35. Calgary Herald (Editorial)
  36. Calgary and Red Deer City Planners
  37. Canada Census Committee
  38. Canadian Association of Professional Employees
  39. Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives (CCPA) / Centre canadien pour des politiques alternatives
  40. Canada West Foundation
  41. Canada Without Poverty Advocacy Network
  42. Canadian Alliance of Student Associations (CASA) / Alliance canadienne des étudiants (CASA)
  43. Canadian Anthropology Society / Société canadienne d’anthropologie (CASCA)
  44. Canadian Association for Business Economics (CABE) / Association canadienne des économistes d’affaire
  45. Canadian Association of Geographers / Association canadienne des géographes
  46. Canadian Association of Journalists / Association canadienne de journalisme
  47. Canadian Association of Midwifes (CAM)
  48. Canadian Association of Public Data Users (CAPDU) / Association canadienne des usagers de données publiques
  49. Canadian Association of Research Libraries (CARL) / Association canadienne des librairies de recherche
  50. Canadian Association of Retired People (CARP)
  51. Canadian Association of Social Workers (CASW)
  52. Canadian Association of University Teachers (CAUT) / Association canadienne des professeurs d’université
  53. Canadian Chamber of Commerce
  54. Canadian Conference of the Arts
  55. Canadian Council on Social Development / Conseil canadien du développement social
  56. Canadian Catholic Council of Bishops & here
  57. Canadian Economics Association
  58. Canadian Evaluation Society / Association canadienne d’évaluation
  59. Canadian Federation of Demographers / Association canadienne des démographes
  60. Canadian Federation of Humanities and Social Sciences / Fédération canadienne des sciences humaines et sociales
  61. Canadian Federation of Independent Business / Fédération canadienne des entreprises indépendante
  62. Canadian Federation of Students
  63. Canadian Restaurant and Food Services Association
  64. Elizabeth Hanson, Yukon NDP Leader
  65. Canadian Historical Association / Société historique du Canada
  66. Canadian Housing and Renewal Association
  67. Canadian Institute of Actuaries / l’Association canadienne des actuaires
  68. Canadian Institute of Transportation Engineers
  69. Canadian Institute of Planners / Fédération canadienne des urbanistes & Statement by Marni Cappe
  70. Canadian Index of Wellbeing
  71. Canadian Islamic Congress
  72. Canadian Jewish Congress / Congrès Juif Canadien
  73. Canadian Labour Congress / Congrès canadien des travailleurs
  74. Canadian Library Association
  75. Canadian Marketing Association / Association canadienne de marketing
  76. Canadian Medical Association Journal
  77. Canadian Medical Association
  78. Canadian Mental Health Association
  79. Canadian Network of Metropolis Centers / Réseau canadien des centres Metropolis
  80. Canadian Nurses Association / Société des infirmières du Canada
  81. Canadian Population Society / Association canadienne de population
  82. Canadian Public Health Association / Association canadienne de santé publique
  83. Canadian Research Data Network Centre / Réseau des centres de données de recherche
  84. Canadian Society for Epidemiology and Biostatistics (CSEB) / Société canadienne d’épidémiologie et de statistiques
  85. Canadian Sociology Association / Association canadienne de Sociologie
  86. Canadian Union of Public Employees (CUPE) / Syndicat Canadien de Fonction Publique (SCFP)
  87. Canadian Urban Institute / Association canadienne de développement urbain
  88. Canadian Women’s Foundation
  89. Capital Regional District (in B.C.)
  90. Mel Cappe, former Clerk of the Privy Council
  91. Carleton University Graduate Student Association (GSA)
  92. Carleton University Undergraduate Student Association (CUSA)
  93. Carleton University Academic Staff Association (CUASA)
  94. Catholic Civil Rights League
  95. Central Toronto Community Health Centres
  96. Centre francophone de Toronto
  97. Centre for Study of Living Standards / Centre de recherche pour niveau de vie
  98. Centre interuniversitaire québécois des statistiques sociales / CIQSS-QICSS / Quebec Inter-University Centre for Social Statistics
  99. Chinese Canadian National Council
  100. Children’s Aid Society of Toronto
  101. Cities Centre – University of Toronto Research Institute
  102. Cityspaces Consulting Ltd.
  103. Citizens Engaging Democracy, Newmarket-Aurora
  104. City of Burnaby
  105. City of Brampton
  106. City of Calgary
  107. City of Charlottetown
  108. City of Edmonton
  109. City of Fredericton
  110. City of Greater Sudbury
  111. City of Hamilton
  112. City of Kelowna
  113. City of Kitimat
  114. City of Langley
  115. City of Laval
  116. City of Mississauga
  117. City of Montreal
  118. City of North Vancouver, and Minutes
  119. City of Merritt
  120. City of Montreal
  121. City of Ottawa
  122. City of Prince George
  123. City of Red Deer
  124. City of Spruce Grove
  125. City of Surrey
  126. City of Toronto, and other info.
  127. City of Vancouver
  128. City of Vernon
  129. City of Victoria
  130. Collectif de bibliothécaires du Québec (Jo-Ann Belair, Annie Bérubé, Stéfano Biondo, Joë Bouchard,Chantal Beauregard, Pierre Carrier, Pierre Chicoine, Nancy Drolet, Alain Gendron, Catherine Jalbert, Guy Julien, Christian Lacroix, Dominique Lapierre, Marie-Denise Lavoie, Louise Leblanc, Sonia Léger, Véronique Paré, Normand Pelletier, Marcel Plourde, Gaston Quirion, Rose-Marie Racine-April et Chantal St-Louis)
  131. Co-operative Housing Federation of Canada / Fédération Canadienne des Coopératives de Logement
  132. Committee of Presidents of Statistical Societies
  133. Commission des droits de la personne et des droits de la jeunesse
  134. Commissariat aux langues officielles
  135. Community Development Halton (Ontario)
  136. Community Development Council Durham
  137. Community Foundations of Canada
  138. Community Social Planning Council of Greater Victoria
  139. Confédération des associations étudiantes de l’Université Laval (CADEUL)
  140. Conseil consultatif sur la condition de femme du Nouveau-Brunswick
  141. Concordia Student Union
  142. Conference Board of Canada
  143. Conference des Lecteurs et Principaux des University de Quebec / Conference of Rectors and Principals of Quebec Universities (Association of Universities in Quebec)
  144. Conférence régionale des élus (CRÉ) de Laval
  145. Conseil permanent de la jeunesse (CPJ)
  146. Conseil des agences servant les immigrants
  147. Conseil Québécois des Coopératives et des Municipalités
  148. Conservative MP James Rajotte
  149. Cornwall Agape Centre
  150. Daily Bread Food Bank (Toronto)
  151. Davenport Perth Community Health Centre
  152. Département de démographie of Université de Montréal
  153. District of Nipissing Social Service Admin Board
  154. Doctors Nova Scotia
  155. Don Drummond; former chief economist of TD bank, former ADM of Finance
  156. Economic Development Association of British Columbia (EDABC)
  157. Edmonton Journal, Editorial
  158. Evangelical Fellowship of Canada / Alliance Évangélique du Canada
  159. Environics Analytics
  160. Fair Share Peel
  161. Family Service Association of Toronto
  162. Research, Evaluation and Planning
    Family Service Toronto
  163. Federation of Post-Secondary Educators of BC
  164. Fédération canadienne de démographie
  165. Fédération des associations étudiantes du Campus de l’Université de Montréal (FAÉCUM)
  166. Fédération des chambres de commerce du Quebec
  167. Féderation des Communautés Francophones et Acadiennes du Canada (FCFA)
  168. Fédération des travailleurs et travailleuses du Québec
  169. Fédération étudiante collégiale du Québec (FECQ)
  170. Federation of Canadian Municipalities / Fédération canadienne des municipalités
  171. Fédération étudiante universitaire du Québec (FEUQ)
  172. Fédération Québécoise des Professeurs et Professeures d’Universités
  173. Greg Finnegan, director of the Yukon Bureau of Statistics
  174. Dr. Robin Fitzgerald, Research Fellow, Key Centre for Ethics, Law, Justice and Governance, Griffith University, Canadian Scholar Downunder
  175. Four Villages Community Health Centre
  176. Front d’action populaire en réaménagement urbain (FRAPRU)
  177. Ivan Fellegi, Former Chief Statistician, Statistics Canada
  178. Tom Flanagan, University of Calgary
  179. French Language Services Commissioner of Ontario / commissaire aux services en français de l’Ontario
  180. Glendon School of International and Public Policy
  181. Globe and Mail Editorials
  182. Stephen Gordon, economist Université Laval
  183. Government of Nunavut
  184. Frank Graves, EKOS Research (polling)
  185. Greater Halifax Partnership
  186. Greater Victoria Community Indicators Network
  187. Green Party of Canada / Parti vert du Canada
  188. Grey County
  189. Halifax Chronicle-Herald, Editorial
  190. Halton, Region of
  191. Hamilton’s Settlement and Integration Services Organization
  192. Hamilton Roundtable for Poverty Reduction
  193. Hamilton Community Foundation
  194. Headwaters Communities in Action (HCIA)
  195. The Hill Times editorial
  196. Alex Himelfarb, former Clerk of Privy Council
  197. Imagine Canada
  198. Information and Communications Technology Council
  199. Institut de statistiques Quebec / Statistical Institute of Quebec
  200. Institute for Research on Public Policy
  201. Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami / Association nationale Inuit (du Canada)
  202. JJ McCullough
  203. Kevin Milligan, economist at University of British Columbia
  204. Liberal Party of Canada / Parti Libéral du Canada
  205. Lumina Research Valuation and Advisory Services
  206. Maclean’s Magazine (Articles)
  207. Marketing Research and Intelligence Association (MRIA) / Association de la Recherche et de Intelligence Marketing (ARIM)
  208. Roger Martin, Rotman School of Management
  209. Patricia J. Martens PhD, Director, Manitoba Centre for Health Policy; CIHR/PHAC Applied Public Health Chair; Professor, Department of Community Health Sciences, Faculty of Medicine, University of Manitoba
  210. Martin Prosperity Institute
  211. Dr. McKeown, Medical Officer of Health, City of Toronto
  212. Kelly McParland (editor of Full Comment, the National Post)
  213. Medical Health Officers Council of Saskatchewan
  214. Metcalf Foundation
  215. Métis National Council (MNC)
  216. Metropolis British Columbia
  217. Metro Vancouver (AKA GVRD)
  218. Metro Vancouver Housing Committee
  219. Mike Moffatt
  220. David Murakami Wood, Queen’s University
  221. Nanos Research (polling)
  222. National Council of Women of Canada (NCWC)
  223. National Post Editorial
  224. National Specialty Society for Community Medicine
  225. National Statistics Council (French Statement) / Association statistique du Canada
  226. Nature International Editorial
  227. New Democratic Party of Canada / Nouveau Parti Démocratique du Canada
  228. New Heights Community Health Centres
  229. North Bay Parry Sound District Health Unit
  230. North Western Ontario Municipal Association
  231. Oak Park Neighbourhood Centre
  232. Office of the Ombudsmen, City of Toronto
  233. Official Language Commissioner
  234. Ontario Chamber of Commerce
  235. Ontario Council of Agencies Serving Immigrants
  236. Ontario Council of University Libraries
  237. Ontario deputy finance minister Peter Wallace
  238. Ontario Human Rights Commission (OHRC)
  239. Ontario Non-Profit Housing Association (OPNHA)
  240. Ontario-Municipal Social Services Association (OMSSA)
  241. Ontario Professional Planners Institute
  242. Ontario Public School Boards Association
  243. Opportunities Waterloo Region
  244. Orillia Packet and Times (Editorial)
  245. Dr. Sylvia Ostry, Former Chief Statistician
  246. Ottawa Citizen Editorial
  247. PARC (Toronto)
  248. Peel, Regional Municipality
  249. Peel Children’s Aid / Aide à l’enfance région de Peel
  250. Peel Poverty Action Group (PPAG)
  251. Peterborough’s medical officer of health
  252. Pickard &Law Firm
  253. Pillar Nonprofit Network
  254. Planning Council of Cambridge and North Dumfries (Cambridge,Ont.)
  255. Planning Institute of British Columbia (PIBC)
  256. Blake Poland, Associate Professor, Dalla Lana School of Public Health, University of Toronto
  257. John Pliniussen, Queen’s University
  258. Poverty Free Halton
  259. Valerie Preston, director of CERIS research centre on immigration and settlement issues York University
  260. Prentice Institute at University of Lethbridge
  261. The Professional Institute of the Public Service of Canada
  262. Province of Manitoba
  263. Province of New Brunswick
  264. Province of Ontario
  265. Province of Ontario – Office of Francophone Affairs
  266. Province of Prince Edward Island
  267. Province of Quebec
  268. Public Service Alliance of Canada (PSAC)
  269. Quebec Community Groups Network
  270. Queen’s University
  271. Queer Ontario
  272. John Rafferty, MP
  273. Research Centre on Digital Inclusion / Centre de recherche et d’expérimentation sur l’inclusion numérique (CREIN)
  274. Regent Park Community Health Centre
  275. Region of Waterloo
  276. Regional Planning Commissioners of Ontario
  277. Registered Nurses Association of Ontario
  278. Richard Florida, University of Toronto
  279. Residential and Civil Construction Alliance of Ontario (RCCAO) / Alliance de la construction résidentielle et civile de l’Ontario
  280. Royal Society of Canada
  281. Rural Ontario Institute (ROI)
  282. St. Joseph’s Health Centre
  283. St. Stephen’s House
  284. Saskatchewan Students’ Union (USSU)
  285. Sexual Assault and Violence Intervention Services (SAVIS)
  286. Munir A. Sheikh, Former Chief Statistician of Canada
  287. Martin Simard,  laboratoire LERGA, Département des sciences humaines et CRDT, Université du Québec à Chicoutimi
  288. Simcoe County
  289. Andrejs Skaburskis, Queen’s University
  290. Social Planning Council of Kitchener-Waterloo
  291. Social Planning Council of Ottawa
  292. Social Planning Council of Sudbury
  293. Social Planning Network of Ontario
  294. Social Planning Toronto
  295. Social Planning Council of Winnipeg
  296. Social Policy in Ontario
  297. Société franco-manitobaine
  298. Société de l’Acadie du Nouveau-Brunswick
  299. Social Development Council of Cornwall and Area (SDC)
  300. South Riverdale Community Health Centre
  301. SPARC BC (Social Planning and Research Council of BC)
  302. StarPhoenix [Saskatoon ] Editorial
  303. Statistical Society of Canada
  304. Statistics Canada Advisory Committee
  305. Statistics Canada Advisory Committee on Demographic Statistics and Studies / Comité consultatif sur les études et les statistiques démographiques de Statistique Canada
  306. Sudbury Star, Editorial
  307. Surrey Board of Trade (BC)
  308. Syndicat des employés internationaux unis (SEIU)
  309. Table régionale des organismes communautaires autonomes en logement de Laval (TROCALL)
  310. Tasha Kheirridin
  311. Toronto Association for Business Economics
  312. Toronto Board of Trade
  313. Toronto Board of Health
  314. Toronto Immigrant Employment Data Initiative (TIEDI)
  315. Toronto Public Health / Directeur de santé publique de Toronto
  316. Toronto Star Editorial
  317. Toronto Social Research and Data Consortium (30 health, community and multi-service social agencies)
  318. Toronto Women’s Housing Co-op
  319. Town of Caledon
  320. Town of Halton Hills
  321. Town of Milton
  322. Town of Smith Falls
  323. Transportation Association of Canada / Conseil du transport urbain du Canada
  324. Ukrainian Canadian Congress / Congrès Canadien Ukrainien
  325. United Church of Canada
  326. United Steelworkers
  327. United Way of Calgary
  328. United Way of Canada
  329. United Way of Kitchener-Waterloo and Area
  330. United Way of Greater Simcoe County
  331. United Way Toronto
  332. Université de Toronto
  333. Urban Public Health Network
  334. Urban Futures
  335. Vancouver Board of Trade
  336. Volunteer Toronto
  337. Waterloo, Region of
  338. Waterloo Students Planning Advisory
  339. Wellesley Institute
  340. West Hill Community Services
  341. West Toronto Support Services
  342. Winnipeg Regional Health Authority
  343. WoodGreen Community Services
  344. Women’s Hands Community Health Centre
  345. York Community Services
  1. National Citizens Coalition census
  2. The Fraser Institute
  3. Lorne Gunther and Ezra Levant, National Post
  4. Canadian Taxpayers Federation
  5. Toronto Sun editorial
  6. Terence Corcoran, Columnist National Post
  7. Red Deer MP Earl Dreeshen
  8. Kenora Mayor, Len Compton
  9. The Province Newspaper
  10. Rafe Mair, Columnist
  11. Mark Warawa, Langley MP

Other Lists:

  1. pabsta aka Pier-Andre Bouchard St-Amant maintains a fabulous list of ceux qui Appuis au questionnaire long obligatoire
  2. CAPDU: List of media stories from CIQSS at l’Universite de Montreal
  3. David Eaves: Save the Census Coalition
  4. Professional Coalition
  5. CIQSS-QICSS
  6. Census Supporters Numerous
  7. gordbot Mathematicians don’t buy lottery tickets
  8. The Toronto Star: Full Coverage
  9. Just a tad more than Mounties, Beavers and Maple Syrup: Letters from and to tony

Other Media Round Ups:

Actions:

  1. Social Planning Council of Toronto: Save our Census
  2. New Brunswick Advisory Council on the Status of Women Take Action et En action; A woman’s View & Le point de vue d’une femme
  3. Caledon Institute of Social Policy:  Stand up for good government, MPs*
  4. Canadian Council on Social Development:  Toolkit
  5. Community Dispatch: Changes To 2011 Census Threaten Community Data and
  6. Citizens Engaging Democracy, Newmarket-Aurora
  7. Vote on the Digital Strategy Submission: Reinstate the Census Long Form
  8. Letter Writing: Canadian Institute of Planners
  9. Petition: Keep the Canadian Census Long Form Petition
  10. Facebook Page: Keep the Canadian Census Long Form
  11. Opinion: Survey

This list was initially compiled by W. T. Stanbury (wstanbury@prodigy.net.mx) and Armine Yalnizyan, Canadian Centre for Policy Analysis and now it expanded as a result of numerous contributors from individuals across the country. I have also merged information from the list of lists above. I get articles from web crawls, #census #statcan #cdnpoli, blogs and what people send.

Graphic By http://www.socialsignal.com/

Bill Stanbury

Bill Stanbury’s avatar

Could you please make a small change to the attribution of the list of organizations–it should be Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, and add Ms Yalnizyan’s e-mail address: armine@policyalternatives.ca

Thanks. W.T.Stanbury,Professor Emeritus,UBC

Great list! Thanks for doing the work on this.

Please add the Public Service Alliance of Canada to your list as per this article on our website.
http://psac.com/news/2010/issues/20100722b-e.shtml

Now let’s just hope that the opposition can capitalize on this… Somehow I am not optimistic and still worry that we’ll end up with a Harper majority by 2011.

Thanks for the great work. You are welcome to add the Registered Nurses’ Association of Ontario to the list of organizations against the government’s decision on the census.

http://www.rnao.org/Storage/71/6521_RNAO_Letter_to_Harper_Census_Concerns_July_20_2010.pdf

Kalen Anderson

Kalen Anderson’s avatar

Please add the “Alberta Professional Planners Institute” to your list of organizations against the census change. Thanks!

Time for Minister Clement to feel the love…

Thankfully, there’s still more than one way to be counted in this country. If you’re opposed to the Harper government’s move to abolish the mandatory long form census, it’s time to do something concrete about it:

1. Contact the opposition riding association of your choice in Minister Clement’s riding of Parry Sound – Muskoka and make a donation and/or volunteer for the next federal election campaign. Websites below:

Parry Sound – Muskoka Federal Liberal Association
http://psmfla.ca/

Parry Sound – Muskoka NDP Riding Association
http://ndpparrysoundmuskoka.ca/

Parry Sound – Muskoka Green Party
http://www.psmgreenparty.ca/

2. Send an email message to Minister Clement’s riding association (http://conservativeparrysoundmuskoka.com/contact.html ) expressing your opposition to the government’s decision to abolish the mandatory long form census, and telling them that you are donating funds and/or your time to help ensure Minister Clement does not return to Ottawa.

Maybe they can talk some sense into him…

FYI, the Association of Ontario Health Centres (AOHC), representing over 100 Community Health Centres, Aboriginal Health Access Centres and Community Family Health Teams also opposed the census decision.

See: http://www.aohc.org/aohc/index.aspx?ArticleID=454&lang=en-CA

Hi, that’s a great service you’re doing for Canadians.

You might want to add Warren Kinsella to your list of those who supports the change to the census.

http://warrenkinsella.com/2010/07/leakage/

http://warrenkinsella.com/2010/07/census-senselessness-from-todays-hill-times/

Liz Jefferson

Liz Jefferson’s avatar

Please add “Citizens Engaging Democracy, Newmarket-Aurora” to the list of organizations AGAINST the government decision. Thanks for your hard work and excellent info resources.
http://www.facebook.com/home.php?#!/group.php?gid=257710977525&ref=ts

Please add the Canadian Library Association to your list AGAINST the government decision. Their press release and official statement can be found here:

http://www.cla.ca/AM/Template.cfm?Section=Home&TEMPLATE=%2FCM%2FContentDisplay.cfm&CONTENTID=9842

Add pretty much everyone, like me, who’s ever worked the census and discovered how open and honest Canadians are when required to share data aimed at improving their lives.

Just updated the info from the comments! thanks bunch. I was away for a couple of days! Sorry for the delay!

added them to the action list – cheers!

Thx for sending this.

Please add the Canadian Institute of Transportation Engineers to the list of organizations AGAINST the Government decision.

Cheers! If you have a link to a letter or statement I will add it too.

Darryl Walker, President of the BC Government and Service Employees’ Union, just posted a blog decrying this short-sighted move. Please add to the list of those opposed to this move.

http://www.bcgeu.ca/Census_changes_will_deal_a_blow_to_public_services

Every five years I dutifully fill out our country’s census and I look forward to the results. They tell us where we are as a country and allow governments, stakeholders and average citizens to form opinions and make decisions based on reliable data about our current situation.

Since the federal government announced their intention to scrap the long-form census, statisticians across the country and across the world are up in arms about a move that they say will render our once-revered statistical data extremely unreliable.

But Minister Tony Clement says that the long form is too intrusive and that Canadians should not be threatened with jail time for not wanting to divulge things like how long they spend doing housework or when they leave for work in the morning. In reality, no one has ever gone to jail for not filling out the census. And the data that is collected, as unnecessarily detailed as some of it may seem, is used for important policy decisions at all levels of government.

This decision is clearly ideologically based. While trying to pander to a small group of right-wingers, Harper is striking a critical blow towards policymakers’ ability to develop and deliver effective social programs.

At the same time, the loss of reliable statistical data will make it much more difficult for stakeholders, like unions and non-profits, to participate in policy discussions in a meaningful way.

The new voluntary survey that the Conservatives have proposed to replace the long-form census does not include questions that previously existed about home care. This undermines the ability of governments to adequately plan for the delivery of home support services.

Worst of all, statisticians argue that replacing the long-form census with an optional survey will mean that key groups, mostly groups that are already marginalized like poor people, new immigrants and people living with disabilities, will be less likely to fill it out and will therefore be even more underrepresented than they already are.

Many BCGEU members work in programs devoted to these underrepresented groups and I worry that without reliable data that lets us know which programs are needed where, that all programs and the people they serve will suffer.

The Province newspaper in BC published an editorial mocking those who opposed this move:

http://www.theprovince.com/news/Freedom+from+census+busybodies+feels+great/3265590/story.html

Matthew Bergbusch

Matthew Bergbusch’s avatar

http://www.acep-cape.ca/EN/specialNotice3/

Canadian Association of Professional Employees

Please add our organization to the “against” list. We rely on the stats can information to ensure our programs are meeting the diverse needs of our community. Oak Park Neighbourhood Centre

Please update your link under the Canada West Foundation entry in the “against” list to the following URL, which is a more complete description of our position.
Thanks.
http://blog.cwf.ca/2010/08/09/thoughts-from-the-ceo-long-form-census/

Having equal access to data is a fundamental requirement in order to make sound analysis and relative comparison.

Hi Tracey,

I just wanted to reiterate the stance of the BCGEU and our President: as noted above, we are opposed to this move. Can you add us to the list above? And add the Province newspaper to those in favour.

Cheers,
Brenton

done! Thanks Brenton,

In Canada there is a polarization on the subject of the mandatory census. People “for ” the census speak of the need for the data and it’s value in formulating smart government policy. People “against” the decision talk of their rights and coercion, and does a group have the right to demand an individual answer questions about their life against their will, under threat of fine and jail.
So what’s more important, the group/state/country/collective or the rights of the individual? Hasn’t this question been played out countless times over the centuries around the world? How was this question settled? I guess it depends which country you live in. Some countries certainly protect the rights of the individual over the right of the group a lot better than others.
If you study sociology or anthropology or philosophy, it is easy to identify these concepts in other populations/countries/ historical periods, but every population and individual is blind to these concepts in their own group. What do you do when the truth of your group conflicts with the truth of an individual?
“StatsCan does great work for Canada.” (Truth for our group/Country/population.)
“I’ll ask the economists, politicians, and government agencies to keep their unwanted, uncomfortable questions off of me.” (Truth for the single mother who feels uncomfortable with the questions the census informs her she must answer, and refuses to answer)

Hence this debate, because the existence of people who don’t answer the census questions, or answer them incorrectly, or write “object to question” for the reply poses an inconvenient truth for the group (“us Canadians”).
In fact, if you look at census data from all countries, including Canada, there are a significant number of respondents who mark some answers as “object to question”. Many others answer some questions in obviously incorrect ways which are understood but are not counted (eg. marking Jedi as their religion). It’s not easily known how many people purposely answer incorrectly and have these incorrect answers erroneously counted as accurate by Statistics Canada. Statistical agencies around the world don’t like to talk about this problem, because it skews the data and puts the validity of all their work at risk.
Now that the issue has been politicized, we even have some people who are “for” the mandatory census saying that people who object to the questions don’t really exist. I’d be careful with that line of thought.
Everyone knows the census provides valuable data. No one is saying the data is not. You won’t win the argument by listing the hundreds of groups and organizations who want and need this data, unless you deal with why coercion of individuals to get this data is acceptable in this case.

Is the following acceptable?

Single Mother: “I feel uncomfortable with you and your questions. Please stop contacting me and leave me alone. I feel you are harassing me and I’m asking you to please stop. I know my rights.”

StatsCan worker: “We don’t care how you feel, you must answer our questions about your life. I am doing nothing wrong, this is my job. You are the one breaking the law and we can fine you or put you in jail for your behaviour. We will keep contacting you. We will keep coming by your home. We have your name and we have taken a description of you. We want much more information than you have provided and you are being uncooperative. There is nothing you can do about this. You are wrong and you do not have any rights in this situation.” (Truth for the statscan worker who has a quota to reach, and is dealing with uncooperative, unhelpful, anti-government people who are purposely not answering these mandatory census questions properly.)

The standard in the western world for data collection from individuals is informed consent, (with the one and only exception of the mandatory census). Maybe it’s time to look at this issue and have a real debate about the issues.

This really long list of the people and groups who use and need this data and support the mandatory census is also a list of people who are for coercion and don’t believe in informed consent.

Thanks Chantal.

Citizens have to pay taxes, not idle in their cars in the summer heat, send their kids to school, present a health card when they go to the hospital, or need a license to do a whole host of things. It is a fair trade in a democratic society, or else, we have no money to manage the nation, we get more carbon in the air that affects respiratory health, kids will not get the tools they and we need to be good and informed citizens, any one can just travel to Canada to use the health care system, or well, the roads would be crazy if we let unlicensed drivers on the road. We live in a collective, and to better direct and strategically spend, we need good data, a mandatory census ensures good data. Those on the list understand that citizenship in a democracy has tradeoffs, and the mandatory long form census is one of them.

Statistics Canada, when they do their follow-up on the census, are pretty great at informing people why they are asking those questions and how they use the data. For the single parent, it means understanding time limitations, the need for childcare, perhaps income supplements, social and recreational programs at a fair price in her neighbourhood. Information helps make decisions on a variety of things that improve our lives. A few minutes of annoyance is worth the return.